The great divide begins around “Captain Mike”
I had been reserving judgment about how “Captain Mike Across America” would be well and truly received until it had its public screenings. So far the only people to see the film were critics and reviewers, who, as I have discussed in previous articles, have unanimously and harshly panned Moore’s newest opus. What I wanted to know is if Moore’s diehard fans would see the same flaws and problems in “Captain Mike” that the critics did - even the critics that were self-proclaimed big fans of Michael Moore and his work. The question I wanted answered was would Moore’s fans still like and appreciate “Captain Mike” despite the critical backlash?
Today we had our first answer to that question. Doc Blog, one of the TIFF 2007 blogs, describes in detail the events that occurred at the first public screening of “Captain Mike Across America”. It was, to put it mildly, a huge and unbridled success with the fans in attendance:
Ryerson theatre was filled to capacity tonight for the premiere of Michael Moore’s latest documentary Captain Mike Across America. The crowd received Moore with the utmost admiration, as reflected by the loud applause when he entered the theatre…
Throughout the screening, the audience burst into applause and at times even motional reactions. A woman a few seats from me cried during one of Moore’s speeches about the war and the lives lost because of it. The energy in the theatre was palpable to say the least. The screening felt like an instant part of Festival lore as Harvey Weinstein was in the audience watching for the first time. This continued to the end, where Moore received a standing ovation for about 2-3 minutes. His reaction was that of the greatest appreciation. He said, “This is way above and beyond what I expected. Thank you for that very generous response.” Moore said the ovation was even longer than when he showed Bowling for Columbine here.
When asked if he would do this journey again for a future election, Moore simply answered, “I hope I don’t have to.” He went on to share how the tour was tiring but also physically dangerous. On more than one occasion, Moore’s life was endangered. His efforts will not go unnoticed when the film gets a theatrical release. You can certainly see why his actions are appreciated by many, many people not just in the US but in other countries as well. This film will have you and others in discussion for some time after you see it.
Judging from this first account, Moore’s fans are responding with great fervor to “Captain Mike Across America”. This fan reaction is a complete 180 turn from the critical reaction, which was resoundingly negative. Several questions emerge now. Is this an isolated report or will more positive fan reactions to “Captain Mike” start popping up? If Moore’s fans do indeed love this new film, why did critics have such a different reaction? What are the critics seeing that Moore’s fans are not? And, perhaps most intriguingly, whose opinion will Moore dwell on the most - the fans or the critics?
Only time will tell, and I will be very curious to see how this continues to play out.
**UPDATE UNDER THE CUT**
A new fan review has just emerged on the web written by a Moore fan from the TIFF festival. The reviewer saw the second public screening of “Captain Mike Across America"… and his reaction was decidedly different from the above review:
I’m not saying anything against Moore’s tactics, but I’m here to review his movie and this movie is just-not-needed. This is Michael Moore’s little love letter to himself. He depicts himself as a hero, standing up on the stage and having us watch him rally these people. And Moore seems to get off having himself large on the screen-even though in his intro he told us how sorry he was for us to be looking at him on a giant screen as he isn’t easy on the eye. Moore seemed to only want to make this to show us how popular he is and how controversial and how he is leading a revolt.Maybe if somebody else made the movie about the tour instead of Moore forcing his vast inspiration on us, I may feel differently. But its still a pointless effort. I like Moore’s films, except “Fahrenheit 9/11, really”, but with “Captain Mike Across America” he is at the peak of his self-indulgent and narcissitic ways. Did he really need to make an entire film about the 2004 elections again? Was there any need for this at all? Maybe if he tookt he footage and cut a twenty minute short on a future DVD of “Fahrenheit 9/11"-which I have a feeling may come out either when “Sicko” comes out on DVD, or right before the 2008 elections.
After the film Moore did a Q&A for the packed audience. Oh I’m sorry, did I say Q&A? What I really should have said was people standing up and saying how much they admire Moore and how his films will change the world without asking anything question, while Moore looked bashful on the stage. No questions. . . no answers. . . nothing. Just a waste of my time. And when the cameraman and editor of the film came on stage, the moderator did ask (because its his job) what the originally intention for this film was. The editor said “When I shot this, we never thought we would make a movie, Michael just wanted to get the tour on film. And then we had this footage and we were wondering what we should do with it.” What I heard as “Fahrenheit 9/11 made over 100 million dollars at the box office, and we have this footage that could probably also make that much money.” “Captain Mike Across America” is really just a self-indulgent little film that is just not needed to see on the big screen. Maybe on TV. . . maybe. Even though the festival screening was like I was at a political rally-and I heard a few anti-American comments by some of the forever Canadian residents, which Moore never really seemed to deny-I sense that Moore fans will see that this is a pointless work. If he wanted to make another documentary so soon he should go in the field instead of releasing dead footage for something that is not needed to see. Come on, the elections are coming up in a year. Do we really need to go back in the past?
Again… WOW. Another scathing review of this movie, but this time by a fan rather than a critic. Will this love-it-or-hate-it trend continue? Stay tuned....
RSS (Subscribe)