Moore is Right.  And Wrong

Posted by MikeS on 11/20/08 at 11:11 AM

You just knew the media was going to have to probe the wisdom of the creator of Roger and Me on the auto industry bailout.  But, surprisingly, Moore actually says something right!  Yeah, I know you don’t believe it.  Here it is:

I’ll tell you, it was hilarious just watching these CEOs there (Tuesday) and (Wednesday) testifying in Congress, saying that, you know, that the problem wasn’t theirs, you know, the cars they were building. It was the financial situation that we’re in now.

The problem is the cars they’ve been building. They’ve never listened to the consumers. They’ve just gone about it their own wrong way. I’ll tell you, you know, I’m of mixed mind about this bailout, Larry, because I don’t think these companies, with these management people, should be given a dime, because that’s just going to be money going up in smoke or off to other countries.

GM is currently building a $300 million factory in Russia right now to build SUVs, right outside of St. Petersburg. That’s where your money’s going to go, no matter what they say.

Now, granted, he thinks their big problem is building cars overseas rather than here.  He makes no mention of American companies paying 50% more per hour than other companies thanks to union benefits and featherbedding.  And his cure is, if anything, worse than the disease:

President-Elect Obama has to say to them, yes, we’re going to use this money to save these jobs, but we’re not going to build these gas-guzzling, unsafe vehicles any longer.

We’re going to put the companies into some sort of receivership and we, the government, are going to hold the reigns on these companies. They’re to build mass transit. They’re to build hybrid cars. They’re to build cars that use little or no gasoline.

We’re facing a national crisis, not just an economic crisis, but a crisis of the polar ice caps are melting. There’s only so much oil left under the Earth. We’re going to run out of that, if not in our children’s time, our grandchildren’s time.

There’s got to be a plan set out to find other ways to transport ourselves in other ways than using fossil fuels.

Yes, Barack Obama, who drives an SUV, certainly has the expertise to turn around a flailing industry.  With his degrees in Business Management, Engineering and Chemistry, he’s the perfect man to run this industry. One day, we can look forward to the auto industry being run with the same skill and efficiency with which the government runs Amtrak.

But let’s not look a gift horse in the mouth.  Mikey said something right.  He was due to say something right at some point this year as one correct statement per year is his established performance level.  And we, at Moorewatch, are nothing if not fair.

Posted on 11/20/2008 at 11:11 AM • PermalinkE-mail this to a friendDiscuss in the forums



Comments


Posted by crichton  on  11/20/2008  at  07:18 PM (Link to this comment | )

I heard a report on the radio yesterday that 25 years ago the two companies with the worst track record for investing their capital was GM at number one and Ford at number two.  Today GM and Ford still hold the same spots that they did 25 years ago.  Yes, making poor products that weren’t attractive to the masses was poor decision making, but so were the poor investments that they made and continue to make.  The Fords run the Detroit Lions, for crying out loud…

Posted by yngcelt  on  11/24/2008  at  09:19 PM (Link to this comment | )

Mikey said something right.  He was due to say something right at some point this year as one correct statement per year is his established performance level.

Well, like my granddaddy used to say, the sun shines on a dog’s ass some days.
Or even better:
Hell, a broken clock is right TWICE a day.

Personally, I liked how Mikey was on Myspace immediately after the elections taking credit for helping Obama win.
Yeah.....OK Mikey......

Posted by thenixedreport  on  12/05/2008  at  01:49 AM (Link to this comment | )

Well, what Moore wants to happen to the auto making industry is simply nothing more than government control, and we all know how well that ends.  I’m on his mailing list, so I manage to get his latest diatribes, including the one concerning “saving the big 3.” I wrote a comprehensive rebuttal which can be viewed here:

http://tinyurl.com/6m8ulw

Posted by w0rf  on  12/15/2008  at  05:57 PM (Link to this comment | )

And also, the ice caps were growing back last I heard.  But far be it from Moore to let the facts stand in the way of a good crisis.  I’d hate for him to change now.

Posted by dvdguy  on  01/17/2009  at  12:41 AM (Link to this comment | )

"He makes no mention of American companies paying 50% more per hour than other companies”

It is always odd to me that a site like this rail against the average worker making a decent living.

“thanks to union benefits” Yeah… health care and sick days.  Wallstreet “benefits” are.... don’t want to bring them up!

Ya got Wallstreet folks making millions… and lying everyday.... and the ‘bad’ folks are working 9/5.  Odd.

Posted by bismarck  on  01/18/2009  at  10:13 AM (Link to this comment | )

dvdguy, I think you polemics are standing in the way of understanding: MikeS’s “companies paying 50% more per hour” statement is flat-out SAYING that the average worker makes a decent living.

And aren’t you a bit off—aren’t the Wall Street folks the evil bad guys, whereas the 9-to-5 folks are the decent hardworking guys?  Isn’t that the way that old black-and-white cartoon plays out?

Honestly, it must be hard to keep the energy up to be negative…

Page 1 of 1 pages of comments


Post a Comment:

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

The trackback URL for this entry is:

Trackbacks:

  1. Michael Moore is 100% correct on the auto bailout issue

    Moore is sometimes a bit over the top, but on this issue he is right: I’ll tell you, it was hilarious just watching these CEOs there (Tuesday) and (Wednesday) testifying in Congress, saying that, you know, that the problem wasn’t theirs, you know,...
    Tracked on: A Couple Things (67.205.36.215) at 2008 11 20 21:34:45

Member Info

Hello. You will need to Login or Register to post comments.
Subscribe for updates via e-mail


Sponsors



Tip Jar

If you feel we provide a useful site, even if you just come here to disagree, please consider donating a few dollars to help keep the server going. Thank you.

Recent Comments

Last 30 comments

Last 60 comments

Top 5 commenters

Buzz - (1006)
Rann Aridorn - (636)
w0rf - (610)
up4debate - (513)
Belcatar - (468)

Most popular posts

Jim Kenefick and Moorewatch as presented by Michael Moore in Sicko (415)
It's Officially Propaganda When the Enemy Uses It!! (365)
Michael Moore, war profiteer (255)
Armed and Hoserous (248)
How the "new left" does things (232)

Search

Local Search:
Advanced Search
Google Search:

Archives

May 2010
S M T W T F S
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31          


Complete Archives

By category


Statistics


This page has been viewed 8395305 times
Page rendered in 0.3760 seconds
70 querie(s) executed
Total Entries: 1929
Total Comments: 15681
Total Trackbacks: 168
Most Recent Entry: 05/14/2010 01:03 pm
Most Recent Comment on: 04/23/2010 10:44 pm
Total Members: 10788
Total Logged in members: 1
Total guests: 52
Total anonymous users: 0
Most Recent Visitor on: 05/24/2010 04:25 am
The most visitors ever was 2215 on 07/01/2004 06:32 pm

Current Logged-in Members:  MikeS